The quality of evidence in medico legal reports is crucial for determining legal outcomes. When it comes to medical expert witness reports, accuracy and impartiality are essential.
But what is a medico-legal report, and what should you be looking for from your expert witness? In this blog, we explore the details.
What is a medico legal report?
A medical expert witness report is an impartial document created by a qualified and experienced medical professional, such as a Consultant or specialist health professional, which provides an analysis of the medical facts relevant to a case. Medico legal reports are typically requested by UK solicitors during legal proceedings in order to provide additional evidence that strengthens their argument.
The report seeks to summarise the facts of the case and present an unbiased opinion based on the available evidence. In some cases, a medical professional may be called upon to provide oral testimony in court as an expert witness. The most important aspect of any medical expert report is that the conclusions must be based solely on the evidence presented and not influenced by the desires of the other side of the dispute.
What are the components of medico legal reports?
A medico legal report in the UK generally comprises of several elements.
To begin with, an introduction will be included which outlines the purpose and scope of the document, as well as providing any background information pertaining to the case that is being reviewed. Then, the medical expert will review all evidence that has been presented in relation to the client’s case, including medical records, documents, previous assessments and reports from medical colleagues. The expert will meet the client to carry out and examination and assessment. Following this they will provide their opinion on the client in a report. A summary and conclusion will be included to validate the opinions drawn by the expert and explain why they believe it to be correct.
All NRC’s medico legal reports include the Expert’s Declaration and are written in compliance with the Civil Procedure Rules for use in UK Courts.
Why might a legal case require a Medico-Legal report?
In a medico legal case, evidence from a qualified and experienced expert witness must be provided to support any claims of injuries, whether arising from medical negligence, personal injury or catastrophic injury such as following a road traffic accident. Having a reputable expert back up your client’s assertion with evidence of injury is essential to strengthening the validity of their claim. A report should not only demonstrate that an incident has caused lasting damage, but also highlight any residual effects yet to be resolved and suggest further medical input or rehabilitation to be addressed.
A Medico-Legal report is often needed when there is a dispute regarding medical care, injuries or illness. Medico legal reports could also be necessary in cases of a personal injury or catastrophic injury claim. In these instances, medico legal reporting will provide an independent, expert opinion to assess the medical condition involved and what effect it has had on the individual’s physical and psychological health. Medico legal reports are also often requested when there are disputes regarding a person ’s mental health or capacity. This could involve guardianship, access to financial support and other legal matters. In these cases, the medico legal expert will provide a clear understanding of the individual’s mental status and their ability to make decisions for themselves.
How are medico legal reports used in legal claims?
A medicolegal report is an important tool for solicitors representing either side of a case. By relying on the opinion of the medical professional, legal teams can strengthen their arguments and provide compelling evidence to support their position. This helps to ensure that both sides representing clients receive a fair hearing and just resolution. The report can serve as an authoritative source of information that helps to make sense of complex medical matters for the court.
A medico-legal report may also be used to prove liability and to calculate the compensation that will be awarded to the injured person. The report will also give guidance to the court when considering future costs such as rehabilitation and care costs and other expenses associated with ongoing treatment.
If the injured party is yet to fully recover, the medico legal expert may also recommend further medical investigations or treatment that may be required to speed up the recovery process. Such further treatment may include physical therapy, rehabilitation or surgical procedures. These treatment recommendations would be particularly important when the injury is ongoing and requires continuous care.
Who writes a medical expert witness report?
A medical expert report is usually written by a doctor or another healthcare professional who has specialised expertise in the subject matter of the case. This individual is an expert in diagnosing and managing a specific illness, injury, or condition, such as brain or spinal injury, orthopaedic injury, trauma and injuries such as brachial plexus injury. The authority of the medico legal experts is derived from his/her extensive knowledge and experience within the field.
The medical expert will use their knowledge and expertise to provide an opinion on the facts of a case, such as whether a client’s condition is causally related to a certain event, and produce reports as required by the solicitor. Ultimately, the clinician’s testimony can be instrumental in determining liability or establishing causation when determining the outcome of a case.
To ensure the medico legal reports are accepted in court, the expert witness must be qualified and experienced in the relevant medical field. The report should detail their background and qualifications, and explain how the opinion expressed in the report was achieved.
How do I find a medical expert witness to write a report?
With so much riding on the evidence contained in a medico legal report, it’s essential to choose the right provider. A medical reporting agency is a good place for an instructing solicitor to start when considering instructions. At NRC Medical Experts, we have an expansive pool of experienced expert witnesses who can create and present impartial medico-legal reports that hold up under scrutiny. Our team understand the importance of getting the facts right, ensuring all reports are comprehensive, accurate and timely. We assist lawyers, a legal representative and case managers to seek the right expert and understand the circumstances of the case.
Our Medical Expert Witness Directory is an excellent search tool which acts to assist legal teams, barristers and case managers to quickly find the right expert for any particular case. This directory includes profiles of over 40 highly qualified medical professionals, consultants and allied health professionals. With NRC’s services, you can easily identify an expert who is both relevant and available to fulfil the specific needs of each case.
We will work with you every step of the way to ensure success, and provide reports in a timely fashion.
Make an enquiry or discuss instructions
To discuss NRC’s medico-legal services, arrange an instruction or discuss a clients needs, please contact our friendly team.
Find an expert witness
Search our medical expert witness directory